simplymommy.

Toy Minimalism

4 places.

Where to Donate Toys (and What Most Places Won't Take)

Where to donate toys your kids have outgrown: thrift stores, plastic-toy collections, free-giving groups and neighbors, and why most hospitals say no.

By Mara Linden ·

Where to Donate Toys (and What Most Places Won't Take)

The places that take used toys are thrift stores such as the Salvation Army, plastic-toy collections such as Second Chance Toys, free-giving groups such as Buy Nothing and Freecycle, and the people you already know: a family with younger children, a preschool or a church nursery that has asked. The places that usually won’t take them are children’s hospitals, which ask for new items only for infection-control reasons, and many December toy drives, which ask for new, unwrapped toys. Check the place’s own page before you load the car. It saves a second trip.

Before you donate: the three-question sort

A donation is only a donation if someone can use it. The sorting itself, with the child involved, is Retro Modern Mom’s lane, and her guide to decluttering toys without a meltdown covers it. What I add is the test each toy has to pass before it goes in the donate box:

  1. Is it complete? A puzzle with three pieces missing is not a puzzle. A game without its dice is a box.
  2. Is it clean and working? Wiped down, batteries that work, nothing sticky.
  3. Has it been recalled? For anything with batteries, magnets, cords or small parts, a quick check of the CPSC recalls search takes a minute. A recalled toy should not be passed on.

Anything that fails goes in a different pile: repair, recycle or bin. Sending broken toys to a charity doesn’t get rid of them. It hands the disposal job to someone with less time than you.

The four places that take used toys

1. Thrift stores

The simplest drop-off, and open most days. The Salvation Army’s thrift store site lists “Toys” among the gently used items its stores generally accept, alongside books, bicycles and sports equipment. It also says acceptance varies by area and suggests calling 800-SA-TRUCK to check what your local store takes (satruck.org, loaded 2026-11-15). Goodwill and local charity thrift shops are the same kind of drop-off. Each store sets its own rules, so check your nearest store’s page or call it.

Best for: a mixed box of good, complete toys you want gone this week.

2. Plastic-toy collections

Plastic toys are the ones that sit in a landfill longest, so a few groups collect them specifically. Second Chance Toys collects “gently used plastic toys” twice a year, in April for Earth Week and in December for the holidays, and passes them on to children through local organizations. Its rules, from its own FAQ (loaded 2026-11-15): toys must be plastic, clean, in working order, with no missing or small parts, defined as anything that fits through a toilet paper roll. Battery toys are fine if the batteries work, “as the recipients are not in a position to buy replacements”. Its drop-off map covers parts of New Jersey, New York, Philadelphia, Washington DC, Los Angeles and Boston. Outside those areas, it will arrange a drop-off at a local organization if you have or can collect 50 or more plastic toys.

Best for: the big plastic pieces (the kitchen, the garage, the ride-on) and a December clear-out timed to the collection.

3. Free-giving groups

Buy Nothing and Freecycle are local groups where people give and get things for free. Buy Nothing describes itself as a community “for giving and getting stuff, completely for free”, with groups in its app and on Facebook. Freecycle says it is “entirely nonprofit” and that membership is free. You post the toy, a neighbor claims it, and it leaves your porch.

This is the fastest route for the specific things people actively look for: a train set, a play kitchen, a bag of building bricks, a balance bike. It’s also the right place for good toys a thrift store might turn away, such as large items or sets in their original box.

Best for: one or two bigger items, and anything a named family nearby would want.

4. Someone you know

The quickest exit of all is a named person. “These are for your two” clears a bag in a day, and “someone will want these” clears nothing. It’s the same first exit as in what to do with outgrown clothes. A preschool, daycare or church nursery may also take specific items, but only if they’ve asked for them. Ring first, and offer a list rather than turning up with a box.

Best for: toys still in their prime, passed to a child who will use them next month.

The places that usually say no

Children’s hospitals. This is the most common wrong turn, because it feels like the obvious place. Most ask for new items only. Hasbro Children’s Hospital in Rhode Island, for example, says on its donation page (loaded 2026-11-15): “For infection control and the safety of our patients, we are only able to accept donations that are new and recently purchased,” and it cannot accept “gently used or previously owned toys, games, and stuffed animals.” If you’d like to give to a hospital, buy one new item from its wish list.

December toy drives. Many collect only new, unwrapped toys for children to receive as Christmas gifts. Used toys belong in one of the four places above. Read the drive’s own rules before you add anything to the bin.

Shelters and family charities. Some take used toys and many don’t. Policies differ by location, so call first.

Stuffed animals. These are the hardest toys to rehome. Hospitals refuse used ones, and many other places won’t take them either. A clean, well-loved one is often best passed to a family you know or offered in a Buy Nothing group.

Timing: the week before the inflow

The best week to donate toys is the one before birthdays or Christmas, not the one after. Clearing a few toys before new ones arrive keeps the count where it was. That’s one-in, one-out, done in one batch. It also lines up with Second Chance Toys’ December collection and with every thrift store’s busiest shopping weeks.

If the box is bigger than a donation and you’d rather sell, that’s a separate job with its own marketplaces. One Mom’s Guide covers it in decluttering for cash.

FAQ: where to donate toys

Where can I donate used toys near me? Your nearest thrift store, a local Buy Nothing or Freecycle group, or a family you know with younger children. For plastic toys, check whether Second Chance Toys runs a drop-off near you in April or December.

Do children’s hospitals take used toys? Usually not. Hospitals that publish donation rules typically ask for new items only for infection-control reasons. Buy one new item from the hospital’s wish list instead.

Does Goodwill take toys? Goodwill stores are a common drop-off for used toys, but each store sets its own rules. Check your local store’s page or call ahead.

Can I donate stuffed animals? It’s harder than other toys. Many hospitals and charities refuse used stuffed animals. A clean one is easiest to pass to a family you know or post in a free-giving group.

What should I do with broken toys? Don’t donate them. Check your local recycling service for what it accepts, and bin what it doesn’t.

More in Toy Minimalism